ARTEL 21 block …
6.1 · Meaning

The Authored Universe

Bitcoin is a universe authored by us, like this universe is authored by God. We wrote its laws, so we are answerable for keeping them.

In short

A note before we start

This essay is a statement of belief and meaning. It is not a proof. We will not try to win an argument here. The evidence lives in the other essays on this site, and we link to them as we go. If you want numbers, follow the links. If you want to know why the numbers matter to us, read on.

We also want to say who this is for. It is for Bitcoiners of any faith and of none. We will speak about God, because the idea came to us that way, and we will try to speak with respect. You do not need to share our belief to share our concern. A rule is a rule whether you think the universe has an author or not.

Here is the belief, as plainly as we can put it. Bitcoin is a universe authored by us, like this universe is authored by God.

Laws we wrote

Every universe has laws. In ours, we did not choose them. We found them. Light has a speed. Energy is conserved. We can measure these laws, but we cannot vote on them.

Bitcoin is different. Its laws were written down. Satoshi Nakamoto wrote the first draft in 2008.[1] Since then, thousands of people have read the code, run it, argued over it and chosen to keep it. Every person who runs a full node signs that choice again each day. In that sense the laws are ours. We wrote them, and we keep writing them by agreeing to them.

Think about what those laws are.

These read like physics. They are fixed, simple and the same for everyone. A sat in your wallet obeys the same law as a sat in ours. No one gets a better rate. That is the beauty of it. We built a small universe where the rules do not bend for anyone.

The site calls this fixed core L0. It is the part that makes Bitcoin what it is.[2]

What an author owes

Many people believe this universe has an author. Many do not. But even as a picture, the idea teaches something. A good author of a world keeps its laws. The sun rises because the rules hold. Gravity does not take a day off for one person and work twice as hard for another. If it did, nothing could be trusted. No one could plan, build or save.

Whether or not you believe in God, you rely on that steadiness every moment. You rely on it when you walk, when you breathe, when you drop a glass and know it will fall.

We think the same is true for anyone who writes a world. If you write the laws, you owe it to everyone living under them to keep those laws. You do not get to change what a thing is while everyone still calls it by the same name. You do not get to make one unit worth less than another and keep saying they are equal.

Authors are answerable for keeping their own laws.

This is not a burden we chose by accident. It comes with authorship. Because we wrote Bitcoin’s rules, no one else can be blamed when they break. There is no outside power to appeal to. There is only us.

Where we broke our own law

We say this with care, because we are part of the “we” that did it. But the evidence essays on this site show that we broke one of our laws.

The law is simple. One byte equals one byte. Every full node stores every byte it receives. A byte costs the same disk, the same bandwidth and the same work to check, wherever it sits in a block.

Since SegWit activated at block 481,824 in August 2017, the fee market no longer treats every byte the same.[3] Witness bytes are priced at a quarter in vbytes. This is the witness discount. Every full node still stores the whole byte. It only gets paid for a quarter of it.

Here is one real block. Block 774,628, mined on 1 February 2023, held 3,955,272 raw bytes. The fee market priced it as 998,192 vbytes. The network stored 3.96 times what it was paid to store.[4] The full story of that gap is told in The 0.75 MB Gap, and the two layers behind it are explained in The Two Layers of Bitcoin.

The essay The Identity Violation puts it in the plainest terms. A thing should equal itself. Since block 481,824, one byte has not equaled one byte.[5]

There is a second break, and it is quieter. A soft fork is meant to keep old nodes working. But Blind Fork shows how witness data lets us put new rules where old nodes cannot see them. The old node keeps syncing. It reports that all is well. It is checking the envelope and trusting someone else with the letter.[6] In a universe where anyone can verify the laws, we made some laws that part of the universe cannot see.

We do not think anyone meant harm. SegWit fixed real problems. But good intentions do not undo a broken law. A world where 1 sat = 1 sat but one byte does not equal one byte is a world with a crack in it. The uniform byte accounting proposal lays out where that crack sits in the code.

Keeping faith

The answer to a broken law is not to give up on laws. It is to restore the one that broke.

The fix we argue for is uniform byte accounting. Count every byte the same. Keep the parts of SegWit that work, and remove the discount.[4] Then a vbyte is a byte again. What the fee market charges for matches what every full node stores. The invariant comes back: 1 bit = 1 bit.

Nothing in the fixed core has to change for this. The 21 million cap stays. Proof of work stays. Conservation of sats stays. We are not writing a new universe. We are keeping faith with the one we already wrote.

That phrase, keeping faith, matters to us. To keep faith is to stay true to a promise when it would be easier not to. Our promise was written in the rules. It said every unit is equal. Every byte, every bit, every sat. An author who keeps faith with what they made goes back and mends the place where that promise slipped.

It also asks something of each of us. Every person who runs a full node is a small co-author. When we upgrade, we sign. When we refuse, we sign too. So the question is not only what the code should say. It is what we are willing to put our names to.

Why it matters beyond Bitcoin

We want to end humbly. We do not claim that Bitcoin explains the cosmos, or that a blockchain proves anything about God. Those are much bigger questions than ours.

But the parallel moves us. A created universe with fixed laws is a universe you can trust. You can build in it. You can raise children in it. You can plan for a future you will not see. Bitcoin, at its best, offers a small taste of that: a world with laws that hold for everyone, written down where anyone can check them.

Two essays on this site explore the physics side of this as analogy. The Ledgered Universe looks at Bitcoin as a laboratory for the holographic principle. The Landauer Gap looks at what it costs a ledger to remember. Neither is a claim that Bitcoin is physics. Both ask what we can learn by setting the two side by side.

If this universe has an author, that author keeps the laws. Light keeps its speed. Energy keeps its balance. We are much smaller authors of a much smaller world. But we can do the same. We can keep our laws, and mend them when we break them.

That is the whole of our belief. We wrote Bitcoin. So we owe it our faithfulness.

See also
The Identity Violation · Blind Fork · Uniform Byte Accounting · The Ledgered Universe
  1. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. Nakamoto, S., 2008.
  2. The Two Layers of Bitcoin, ARTEL 21. L0, the fixed core, and L1, the layer a soft fork can change.
  3. BIP-141: Segregated Witness. Lombrozo, E., Lau, J. and Wuille, P., 2015.
  4. BIP-?: Uniform Byte Accounting for Bitcoin Blocks, ARTEL 21. The proposal to remove the witness discount, with block 774,628 as a worked example.
  5. The Identity Violation, ARTEL 21. Why one byte has not equaled one byte since block 481,824.
  6. Blind Fork, ARTEL 21. How witness data lets rules sit where old nodes cannot see them.
  7. The 0.75 MB Gap, ARTEL 21. The witness discount and the cost it hands to every node.
  8. The Ledgered Universe, ARTEL 21. Bitcoin and the holographic principle, as analogy.
  9. The Landauer Gap, ARTEL 21. The cost of remembering, as analogy.